Eli Pariser and Sue Halpern discuss important concerns pertaining to internet use and its ability to isolate us into this filter bubble. The information that was once universal and accessible is no longer available for us to see. We should have the right to individually decide what gets tailored or not; it should be our choice not anyone or anything else’s. I agree with Pariser when he says that a democracy cannot function properly if its citizens are not exposed to a “good flow of information.” Needless to say, how can we grow as intellectuals if there is this hindrance preventing us from absorbing new and different ideas that can broaden our outlook on life and humanity? I feel that implementing algorithms to personalize and better our search process is a creative and smart idea but too much personalization blocks us from learning and developing new ideas. With such a personalized web, we have our own ideas thrown back at us and hence, we do not get to explore new ideas or read the ideas and opinions of the dissenting party.
Conversely, Clive Thompson discusses how this phenomenon (homophily) can actually be a good thing and can improve the “diversity of our information diet.” Further, he mentions that sticking with “like-minded” people can actually be more beneficial than we think because it is our closest friends who know what we already know and would know what may be new information to us. According to information economists, Sinan Aral and Marshall Van Alstyne, interacting with a small group of close friends can be useful in that it can provide us with valuable and surprising information. In short, sticking with “our kind” actually may not be such a bad thing. It is true that unlike weak ties your close friends know you best and would know what information is new to you. Moreover, one does not have sufficient interaction with weak ties to constantly obtain new information. Nonetheless, we shouldn’t stop from having “weak” relationships because this may help us in the long run and can provide us with much more useful information than our closest friends can. At the end, I think it is smart to maintain a relationship with both your close friends and weak ties.